Due to a massive screwup by the tour company, I found myself in a UNESCO world heritage site (Olinda) without a capable guide, and no way of getting one at the last second. This is akin to being trapped in an elevator with a beautiful woman and not understanding each other’s language. There’s a limit to how much you can enjoy just looking.
So I agreed to leave lovely little Olinda and drive an hour into one of Brazil’s ugliest modern cities, Recife. I had done some quick research and identified four sites that sounded interesting. Once we got into town, the idiot driver and idiot “guide” remembered that three of them were closed. The best I got from them was the Portuguese equivalent of “oops.”
We did go to the 17th-century Franciscan complex Santo Antonio do Convento de Sao Francisco. The small cloister is lined with large (about 7 feet x 4 feet) tile murals depicting scenes from Genesis (Adam and Eve, Noah & the Flood, etc.), akin to the great stained glass that instructed the semi-literate in so many Renaissance churches.

Once again, I was reminded of how crucial the historic selection of these particular stories was. Imagine if instead of teaching dozens of generations stories about “sin,” blind obedience, and a trust in miracles, people had been learning lessons like “think carefully before making decisions,” “women are excellent companions to men,” and
“mind your own business.” Talk about a lost opportunity.
Anyway, the tiled cloister would have been charming enough, but the famous attraction was the Golden Chapel inside. Finished in 1697, all the baroque floor-to-ceiling ornamentation is meticulously covered with gold leaf. The effect is rather overpowering, like a fudge brownie that’s just too sweet to eat. To a poor laborer this must have been a demonstration of overwhelming spiritual power; to the sugar barons who built it, the demonstration was of another type of power.

The whole thing was fascinating (although terribly under-interpreted by my inept “guide”), and soon we faced the same question again: now what?
So we drove 45 minutes to the edge of town, to the Gilberto Freyre House and Foundation. I had run across Freyre in my recent readings in the sociology and anthropology of race and ethnic relations (I’m eager to tell you about Ruth Landis’s “City of Women,” published in 1947 and just republished). I rarely go to the houses of famous people, but it was simply too hot to stroll around town, so here I was.
Gilberto Freyre was born in Recife in 1900, and was a sociologist, essayist, poet, and politician. By the end of his life he’d been honored by dozens of countries. Like many intellectuals, he went into exile (Portugal, then Stanford University) after the 1930 revolution and the rise of Getulio Vargas. In 1933 he published his most widely known work, The Masters and the Slaves. It detailed a radical new idea: that African culture had value and integrity of its own, and that it enriched, rather than diluted, Brazil’s European culture. To this day, his ideas about race-mixing (not just culturally, but sexually and therefore reproductively) are important for understanding Brazil’s complex social structure. He wrote 80 books, translated around the world.
But somehow this progressive intellectual, champion of non-Western culture, turned to support the Salazar dictatorship in 1950s Portugal, and the Brazilian military dictatorship from the 1960s on. Why? How? And how does today’s democratic Brazil, which (mostly) denounces the old military dictatorship, still embrace Freyre? There was no clue about this in my tour of his old house. The young docent talked endlessly about this piece of furniture, that ashtry, this medal from Queen Elizabeth. But of the thinking that revolutionized Brazil’s (and Europe’s) ideas about race, and the analysis (or deals?) that led to the support of cruel, power-hungry regimes—not a word. Why anyone should bother going to this old house would have to wait for another day. Another lost opportunity.
It was a frustrating drive back to lovely little Olinda. But tomorrow, the golden sands of Praia do Forte await. After flying to Salvador out of Recife’s Gilberto Freyre airport.
You must be logged in to post a comment.